Cooking with Karl: The Great American Potato Salad

Karl Gerhard • July 8, 2026

Creamy, tangy, and packed with classic flavor, this crowd-pleasing potato salad is the perfect side dish for backyard barbecues, family picnics, and America's 250th celebration.

A silver-toned trophy featuring a detailed, circular embossed emblem, mounted on a dark wooden base.

The Great American Potato Salad


While celebrating America 250 this July, you may be hosting or attending a barbecue. Every summer barbecue needs a few sides. There is one cookout side dish that stands alone in popularity and captures the spirit of Americana better than any other: potato salad. 


Try this simple recipe with an infusion of dill pickle juice and celery seed, and you may never make another version of potato salad. It is that good.


Prep time: 10 minutes

Total cook time: 90 minutes, start to finish

Serves: 6–8


Ingredients


 • 3 large eggs, hard-boiled

 • 1 1/2 t Kosher salt

 • 2 pounds Yukon Gold potatoes

 • 1 small red onion (1/2 C petite diced)

 • 2 celery ribs (3/4 C diced)

 • 3 T dill pickle juice

 • 1/4 C finely chopped dill pickles

 • 1 T yellow mustard

 • 1/4 t black pepper

 • 1/2 t celery seed

 • 1/4 C sour cream

 • 1/2 C mayonnaise


Directions


  1. Peel the potatoes and dice into 1-inch cubes.
  2. Place the potatoes into a large saucepan, cover with cold water by 1 inch, add 1 tsp. kosher salt, and bring to a boil over high heat. Once boiling, reduce heat to medium-low and simmer until fork-tender, about 10-15 minutes.
  3. While the potatoes are boiling, finely chop the celery and red onion.
  4. Mix 2 Tbsp. pickle juice and the mustard in a small bowl. Set aside.
  5. Drain the potatoes thoroughly and transfer them to a rimmed baking sheet or pan.
  6. Drizzle the pickle juice and mustard mixture over the hot potatoes and gently toss until evenly coated.
  7. Refrigerate the potatoes for 30 minutes to cool.
  8. While they are cooling, combine the remaining 1 Tbsp. pickle juice, chopped pickles, 1/2 tsp. kosher salt, black pepper, celery seed, celery, onion, mayonnaise, and sour cream in a large serving bowl.
  9. Add the cooled potatoes and gently toss to coat evenly. Cover and refrigerate for 30 minutes. You can make it a day ahead, but fresher is best.
  10. Just before serving, gently stir in the chopped hard-boiled eggs.

"As always, eat fresh, dine local & be happy!"
—Karl Gerhard, Cooking with Karl


A person wearing a grey blazer and white collared shirt stands outdoors in front of a blooming dogwood tree.

Recent Posts

By Laura Briedis • November 17, 2026
Tired of the same old dining routine? Head west and discover six delicious destinations worth the drive.
By Mimi Vanderhaven • November 10, 2026
A little festive cheer, a place to rejuvenate, gifts galore, and the opportunity to get those last-minute projects finished in time for Christmas. It’s all here at home, in Lake County.
By Mitch Allen • November 10, 2026
Attention Contractors: Get the equipment you need and reduce your tax burden.
By Patricia Nugent • November 10, 2026
With more than 50 agents and years of experience selling in this area, Showcase Home Group at eXp Realty is poised to produce more than 550 home sales by the end of 2026.
By Mimi Vanderhaven • November 10, 2026
With two distinct shopping experiences for different personalities, Window & Bath Expo ensure you don’t have to step out of your comfort zone.
By Dr. Sonja Stiller • November 10, 2026
Skin discoloration is a symptom of advanced venous insufficiency.
By Mimi Vanderhaven • November 10, 2026
A little festive cheer, some food for the body and soul, and the opportunity to secure the finest art from Northeast Ohio creators. It’s here at home, in Lakewood.
By Beth Newcomb • November 10, 2026
Local guidance available at no cost can be invaluable when it comes to selecting an ACA plan for 2027.
By Scott McEvoy • November 10, 2026
If you attended high school in 1979, you are likely nearing age 65, the point when you’ll start making decisions about your Medicare options.
By Mimi Vanderhaven • November 10, 2026
Take a magical stroll on the illuminated trail at Lake Metroparks’ Chapin Forest Reservation, where twinkling lights and nature’s quiet beauty make winter evenings something special.

RELATED ARTICLES

By Laura Briedis • November 17, 2026
Tired of the same old dining routine? Head west and discover six delicious destinations worth the drive.
By Mimi Vanderhaven • November 10, 2026
A little festive cheer, a place to rejuvenate, gifts galore, and the opportunity to get those last-minute projects finished in time for Christmas. It’s all here at home, in Lake County.
By Mitch Allen • November 10, 2026
Attention Contractors: Get the equipment you need and reduce your tax burden.
By Patricia Nugent • November 10, 2026
With more than 50 agents and years of experience selling in this area, Showcase Home Group at eXp Realty is poised to produce more than 550 home sales by the end of 2026.
By Mimi Vanderhaven • November 10, 2026
With two distinct shopping experiences for different personalities, Window & Bath Expo ensure you don’t have to step out of your comfort zone.
By Dr. Sonja Stiller • November 10, 2026
Skin discoloration is a symptom of advanced venous insufficiency.
By Mimi Vanderhaven • November 10, 2026
A little festive cheer, some food for the body and soul, and the opportunity to secure the finest art from Northeast Ohio creators. It’s here at home, in Lakewood.
By Beth Newcomb • November 10, 2026
Local guidance available at no cost can be invaluable when it comes to selecting an ACA plan for 2027.
By Scott McEvoy • November 10, 2026
If you attended high school in 1979, you are likely nearing age 65, the point when you’ll start making decisions about your Medicare options.
By Mimi Vanderhaven • November 10, 2026
Take a magical stroll on the illuminated trail at Lake Metroparks’ Chapin Forest Reservation, where twinkling lights and nature’s quiet beauty make winter evenings something special.
More Posts